Hosting Thanksgiving in a New York City apartment comes with its own set of logistics, especially when it comes to shopping, cooking, and finding room for everything (and everyone). Fortunately, putting together a holiday meal doesn’t have to mean preparing every dish from scratch.
We rounded up a few standout places in and around Midtown West to help ARO residents tackle the holiday shopping list, whether hosting dinner or simply bringing something to the table.
Little Pie Company: Thanksgiving Dessert, Handled
424 West 43rd Street, Hell’s Kitchen
When it comes to Thanksgiving dessert, a good pie will always do the job – Little Pie Company has built its business around making precisely this.
Located on West 43rd Street, this bakery is known for its handmade pies, particularly its signature Sour Cream Apple Walnut. Made with sliced Granny Smith apples, sour cream, and a brown sugar, cinnamon, and walnut topping, it’s a departure from the usual double-crust apple pie.
The bakery’s Thanksgiving menu also includes Southern Pecan, Pumpkin, Mississippi Mud, and Salted Caramel Apple pies. Full-size 10-inch pies are $48 and serve approximately eight to ten people. There are gluten-free options as well, including Blueberry Apple Crumb and Key Lime pies.
For ARO residents, Little Pie Company is one of the most convenient specialty bakeries to visit in Hell’s Kitchen.
Éclair Bakery: A French Take on Thanksgiving Classics
303 East 53rd Street, Midtown East
If you’re looking to bring other than a traditional pumpkin pie, Éclair Bakery offers alternatives worth considering.
Established in 2013, the French bakery specializes in éclairs, macarons, cakes, and more. For Thanksgiving, its seasonal menu features four pies: Pumpkin, Pecan, Apple Crumble, and Pear Almond.
The Pear Almond tart is particularly special. It combines pears with almond filling, making it a good alternative to the usual Thanksgiving lineup.
Although Éclair Bakery is on the east side of Midtown, it’s a great option for ARO residents who want to expand their dessert choices beyond the immediate neighborhood.
Whole Foods Market: The Practical One-Stop Shop
10 Columbus Circle, Midtown West
Not every Thanksgiving shopping trip requires a specialty food store. Sometimes you simply need fresh produce, ingredients for the sides, and whatever you forgot to add to the grocery list.
Located inside The Shops at Columbus Circle, Whole Foods Market is a straightforward option for stocking up before Thanksgiving.
The store carries fresh produce, pantry staples, dairy, baked goods, and prepared foods. Its bakery also offers ready-made cakes and custom cake services, while catering options may be useful for residents looking to order food rather than prepare everything from scratch.
For smaller gatherings, shopping here can be especially convenient. Hosts can focus on a manageable menu and supplement it with excellent prepared dishes. Whole Foods also offers grocery pickup at this location, giving residents another convenience during the busy days leading up to Thanksgiving.
Zabar’s: Where Else Handles the Sides
2245 Broadway at West 80th Street, Upper West Side
There are two ways to approach Thanksgiving dinner: cook everything yourself or decide which dishes can be outsourced. For the second approach, Zabar’s is a longtime New York favorite.
This Upper West Side specialty food store is particularly well known for its smoked fish, coffee, cheese selection, and prepared foods. Around Thanksgiving, its offerings extend to complete holiday meals, traditional sides, and desserts.
Individual dishes are also available, so there’s no obligation to order an entire meal. That makes Zabar’s useful for anyone planning to cook the turkey but who wants to assign the mashed potatoes, stuffing, or gravy to someone else.
It’s a trip uptown from ARO, but one that can simplify a considerable portion of Thanksgiving preparation.
Levain Bakery: Something to Bring as a Gift
167 West 74th Street, Upper West Side
For those attending Thanksgiving dinner elsewhere, a box of cookies can be a welcome alternative to arriving with yet another bottle of wine.
Levain Bakery opened its original Upper West Side shop in 1995 and has since become famous for its oversized cookies – particularly the Chocolate Chip Walnut.
This fall, its seasonal selection includes a Fall Spiced Chocolate Chunk cookie made with ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg, molasses, and chocolate. It’s a fitting addition to a Thanksgiving dessert spread without adding on another pie.
Levain also offers assorted cookie boxes, making it easy to bring variety to the dessert table. A selection of Chocolate Chip Walnut, Oatmeal Raisin, and seasonal specials offer something for everyone. While the original shop is farther uptown, it’s an option for ARO residents looking for a recognizable New York bakery gift.
Enjoying Thanksgiving at the Table
Whether you’re planning a full dinner, contributing a side dish, or picking up dessert on the way to someone’s apartment, a little advance planning makes Thanksgiving considerably easier.
Midtown West offers access to everyday grocery shopping, independent bakeries, and established specialty food stores, with additional options just a short trip away. For residents of ARO at 242 West 53rd Street, that means spending less time figuring out where to shop and more time enjoying the holiday.
Explore ARO and discover more about living in Midtown West.
